Should I Install a Metal or a Traditional Shingle Roof?

Homeowners in the market for a new roof are faced with the decision of which material to choose. Traditional shingles and metal roofing are the most popular choices but which one is better? At first you may only think about the price of the material but you also need to consider things like the climate you live in, the longevity of the material, and what kind of maintenance it requires. Both roofing material options offer their own advantages, making the decision a crucial one for long-term satisfaction. In this blog, we will cover the pros and cons of both roofing materials to help you decide which one is best for your home.

Installing A Shingle Roof In Converse, TX

Asphalt Roofing

Traditional asphalt shingles offer affordability, versatility, and easy installation. They are a cost-effective choice for budget-conscious homeowners. Compared to metal roofing, asphalt shingles are generally more budget-friendly. They also offer a wide variety of colors and styles that allow for personalized preferences and enhanced curb appeal. This versatility makes it easier to find an option that complements the overall design of the house and its environment. The lightweight nature of asphalt shingles makes them easy and quick to install which contributes to their lower labor costs and the process is usually quicker than metal roofing installation. Furthermore, when it comes to repairs in the future, shingles can be replaced individually or in small sections as opposed to a full roof replacement.

Shingle roofs do have a few drawbacks to consider though. Shingles may be susceptible to wind uplift and shingle loss, increasing the risk of leaks and potential damage to the roof structure. Shingled roofs are not recommended in areas that are prone to hurricanes and tornadoes for this reason. Additionally, their lightweight nature makes them vulnerable to extreme heat and extreme cold temperatures that can cause them to be brittle, crack, or curl. Routine inspections and repairs are necessary to address these issues and ensure the roof’s integrity. Lastly, compared to other roofing materials, asphalt shingle roofs generally have a shorter lifespan. The lighter weight of shingles contributes to their reduced durability over time compared to stronger roofing materials like metal.


  • Affordable / Cost Effective

  • Color & Style Variety

  • Light Weight

  • Easy To Install


  • Susceptible To Wind Uplift / Shingle Loss

  • Vulnerable To Extreme Heat & Cold

  • Shorter Lifespan

Metal Roofing

Metal roofs offer several notable advantages, with longevity being a key feature. A metal roof can last 40 to 70 years, providing long-term durability. They can last up to two times longer than asphalt shingles. Metal is resistant to weather extremes, such as heavy rain, snow, and severe heat, which helps maintain its structural integrity over time. They are also designed to withstand wind gusts of up to 140 mph, which makes them great for areas that experience tornadoes and hurricanes. Even the Federal Emergency Management Agency, (FEMA), recommends metal roofs for areas that have severe storms and wildfires. Additionally, metal roofs are environmentally friendly as they are often made from recycled materials and are fully recyclable themselves at the end of their lifespan. Metal roofs can also be installed over existing shingles, which reduces waste and contributes to sustainable practices. Finally, although a metal roof may cost more in the beginning, it will save you money in the long run due to being energy efficient. By reflecting radiant heat away instead of absorbing it, metal roofs can help lower energy bills by reducing cooling costs in the summer and reduce the loss of heat in the winter.


  • Lasts Longer

  • Better Weather Resistance

  • Can Withstand Wind Gusts Up To 140 MPH

  • Environmentally Friendly

  • Energy Efficient / Reduction Of Energy Bill


  • High Initial Cost

  • Susceptible To Denting

However, there are cons to metal roofs, the main one being a high initial cost. Metal roofs generally have a higher upfront cost compared to traditional shingles, which can put off some homeowners, especially if they’re on a tight budget. The materials, labor, and time are all higher when it comes to installing a metal roof. Additionally, metal roofs are more durable than asphalt shingles but they can still be susceptible to denting from hail or falling branches. A dent in the metal can lead to rust which will eventually lead to a leak. Routine inspections and preventative maintenance are required to keep your metal roof strong and ensure it lives up to its expected longevity.

Choosing between traditional asphalt shingles and metal roofing ultimately depends on your specific needs and priorities. Asphalt shingles offer affordability, versatility, and ease of installation, while metal roofs provide durability, longevity, and energy efficiency. Take into account your budget, aesthetic preferences, curb appeal in the market, and your environment’s climate before making a final decision.

Do you need more information to help you decide? Contact Kresta Roofing to schedule a free roof inspection and quote. Our roofing contractors can help you decide which is the best roofing option for your house and budget. We are fully licensed and insured, offer warranties on our work, and also offer roof financing. Call us today or fill out the contact form on our website and we’ll be in touch with you shortly.

Do you have a Project we can help with?